Combining Philosophers

Ideas for Baron,S/Miller,K, Michal Walicki and Jan Westerhoff

unexpand these ideas     |    start again     |     choose another area for these philosophers

display all the ideas for this combination of philosophers

---

5 ideas

26. Natural Theory / C. Causation / 1. Causation

23011	Modern accounts of causation involve either processes or counterfactuals [Baron/Miller]
	Full Idea: The two major contemporary theories of causation are process theories and counterfactual theories. …Process theories treat it as something to be discovered. …Counterfactual theories ignore processes, and treat it in terms of truth and falsity.
	From: Baron,S/Miller,K (Intro to the Philosophy of Time [2019], 6.1)
	A reaction: I take the counterfactual theory to be a specialised branch of the project of analytic metaphysics, which seeks the logical form of causation sentences, using possible worlds semantics. In the real word its processes or nothing.

26. Natural Theory / C. Causation / 4. Naturalised causation

23013	The main process theory of causation says it is transference of mass, energy, momentum or charge [Baron/Miller]
	Full Idea: According to contemporary process theories of causation it consists of the transference of a 'mark', which is always some conserved quantity. Candidates (from science) are mass, energy, momentum and electric charge.
	From: Baron,S/Miller,K (Intro to the Philosophy of Time [2019], 6.2.2)
	A reaction: Given my commitment to physicalism, this is my preferred theory of causation. It began with the suggestion of energy-transfer, but has broadened into the present idea. It is an updated version of the Newton view, as the meeting of objects.

23014	If causes are processes, what is causation by omission? (Distinguish legal from scientific causes?) [Baron/Miller]
	Full Idea: Process theories of causation face a serious problem, such as killing a plant by failing to water it - a cause by omission. …Defenders of the theory propose two concepts of causation: one for legal and one for scientific contexts.
	From: Baron,S/Miller,K (Intro to the Philosophy of Time [2019], 6.2.3)
	A reaction: Not much of a problem, I think. Clearly the scientific concept has priority. The plant died of dehydration, resulting from the consumption and evaporation of the available water. The human causes of that situation are legion.

26. Natural Theory / C. Causation / 9. General Causation / c. Counterfactual causation

23015	The counterfactual theory of causation handles the problem no matter what causes actually are [Baron/Miller]
	Full Idea: The chief advantage of the counterfactual theory of causation is that it is flexible enough to handle causation no matter what in the world underlies the causal facts in question.
	From: Baron,S/Miller,K (Intro to the Philosophy of Time [2019], 6.3)
	A reaction: It has this advantage because it makes no attempt to explain causation, but merely gives an accurate map of the truth and falsity of causal statements. It describes how we think about causation.

23016	Counterfactual theories struggle with pre-emption by a causal back-up system [Baron/Miller]
	Full Idea: Counterfactual theories of causation have difficulty accommodating pre-emption, which involves the existence of causal back-up systems that undermine counterfactual dependence.
	From: Baron,S/Miller,K (Intro to the Philosophy of Time [2019], 6.5)
	A reaction: E.g. If your stone hadn't broken the window first, my stone would have broken it instead. So in the nearest world the withholding of your stone doesn't save the window.