display all the ideas for this combination of philosophers
1 idea
6135 | A crumbling statue can't become vague, because vagueness is incoherent [Merricks] |
Full Idea: Some would say that annihilating grains of stone from the statue of David (playing the 'Sorites Game') could never make its identity vague, because metaphysical vagueness is simply unintelligible. | |
From: Trenton Merricks (Objects and Persons [2003], §2.II) | |
A reaction: He cites Russell, Dummett and Lewis in support. But Russell is a logical atomist, and Lewis says identity is composition. It strikes me as obvious that identity can be vague; the alternative is the absurdities of the Sorites paradox. |