more from this thinker     |     more from this text

Single Idea 11903

[filed under theme 10. Modality / E. Possible worlds / 3. Transworld Objects / d. Haecceitism ]

Full Idea

Lewis's strategy for defending extreme haecceitism is that supposed impossibilities (that I might have been a poached egg) could be reconstrued as genuine possibilities that are so remote from reality that they are ignored.

Gist of Idea

Extreme haecceitists could say I might have been a poached egg, but it is too remote to consider

Source

report of David Lewis (On the Plurality of Worlds [1986], 239-) by Penelope Mackie - How Things Might Have Been 9.3

Book Ref

Mackie,Penelope: 'How Things Might Have Been' [OUP 2006], p.155

A Reaction

Not a promising route. Wiggins asks: if you think I could have been a poached egg, start by defining more precisely this 'I' to which we are referring. The definition will blatantly exclude any possibility of my poachedegghood.

The 16 ideas with the same theme [indistinguishable worlds might still have different objects]:

13085 Leibniz is some form of haecceitist [Leibniz, by Cover/O'Leary-Hawthorne]
12869 Two objects may only differ in being different [Wittgenstein]
16451 Adams says anti-haecceitism reduces all thisness to suchness [Adams,RM, by Stalnaker]
11901 Haecceitism may or may not involve some logical connection to essence [Adams,RM, by Mackie,P]
14512 Moderate Haecceitism says transworld identities are primitive, but connected to qualities [Adams,RM]
11990 'Haecceitism' says that sameness or difference of individuals is independent of appearances [Kaplan]
9668 'Haecceitism' is common thisness under dissimilarity, or distinct thisnesses under resemblance [Kaplan]
11991 If quantification into modal contexts is legitimate, that seems to imply some form of haecceitism [Kaplan]
16450 Anti-haecceitism says there is no more to an individual than meeting some qualitative conditions [Stalnaker]
11903 Extreme haecceitists could say I might have been a poached egg, but it is too remote to consider [Lewis, by Mackie,P]
15129 Haecceitism implies de re differences but qualitative identity [Lewis]
9670 Extreme haecceitism says you might possibly be a poached egg [Lewis]
12021 Haecceitism attributes to each individual a primitive identity or thisness [Forbes,G]
12029 We believe in thisnesses, because we reject bizarre possibilities as not being about that individual [Forbes,G]
9491 Haecceitism says identity is independent of qualities and without essence [Bird]
11884 The theory of 'haecceitism' does not need commitment to individual haecceities [Mackie,P]