more on this theme | more from this thinker
Full Idea
The argument that objectual quantifiers are ontologically committing has the crucial and unnoticed presupposition that the language in which the semantics for the objectual quantifiers is couched (the 'metalanguage') also has quantifiers with commitment.
Gist of Idea
If objectual quantifiers ontologically commit, so does the metalanguage for its semantics
Source
Jody Azzouni (Deflating Existential Consequence [2004], Ch.3)
Book Ref
Azzouni,Jody: 'Deflating Existential Consequence' [OUP 2004], p.54
A Reaction
That is, presumably we find ourselves ontologically committed to the existence of quantifiers, and are also looking at an infinite regress. See Idea 12439.
Related Idea
Idea 12439 Truth is dispensable, by replacing truth claims with the sentence itself [Azzouni]
12437 | Truth lets us assent to sentences we can't explicitly exhibit [Azzouni] |
12438 | In the vernacular there is no unequivocal ontological commitment [Azzouni] |
12439 | Truth is dispensable, by replacing truth claims with the sentence itself [Azzouni] |
12442 | 'Mickey Mouse is a fictional mouse' is true without a truthmaker [Azzouni] |
12445 | If fictional objects really don't exist, then they aren't abstract objects [Azzouni] |
12441 | We only get ontology from semantics if we have already smuggled it in [Azzouni] |
12440 | If objectual quantifiers ontologically commit, so does the metalanguage for its semantics [Azzouni] |
12446 | Names function the same way, even if there is no object [Azzouni] |
12448 | Things that don't exist don't have any properties [Azzouni] |
12447 | That all existents have causal powers is unknowable; the claim is simply an epistemic one [Azzouni] |
12449 | Modern metaphysics often derives ontology from the logical forms of sentences [Azzouni] |
12450 | The periodic table not only defines the elements, but also excludes other possible elements [Azzouni] |