more on this theme
|
more from this thinker
Single Idea 15604
[filed under theme 9. Objects / F. Identity among Objects / 5. Self-Identity
]
Full Idea
'Cicero=Cicero' and 'Cicero=Tully' are both dyadic predications. It is unnatural to suppose that the use of the same name converts a dyadic predicate into a reflexive predicate, or that there is one reference to Cicero in the first and two in the second.
Gist of Idea
If Cicero=Tully refers to the man twice, then surely Cicero=Cicero does as well?
Source
Kit Fine (Semantic Relationism [2007], 3.A)
Book Ref
Fine,Kit: 'Semantic Relationism' [OUP 2007], p.69
A Reaction
I am deeply suspicious of the supposed 'property' of being self-identical, but that may not deny that it could be a genuine truth (shorthand for 'the C you saw is the same as the C I saw'). Having an identity makes equality with self possible.
The
18 ideas
from 'Semantic Relationism'
15588
|
You cannot determine the full content from a thought's intrinsic character, as relations are involved
[Fine,K]
|
15587
|
That two utterances say the same thing may not be intrinsic to them, but involve their relationships
[Fine,K]
|
15589
|
The two main theories are Holism (which is inferential), and Representational (which is atomistic)
[Fine,K]
|
15590
|
It seemed that Frege gave the syntax for variables, and Tarski the semantics, and that was that
[Fine,K]
|
15591
|
In separate expressions variables seem identical in role, but in the same expression they aren't
[Fine,K]
|
15592
|
The usual Tarskian interpretation of variables is to specify their range of values
[Fine,K]
|
15593
|
Variables can be viewed as special terms - functions taking assignments into individuals
[Fine,K]
|
15595
|
The 'algebraic' account of variables reduces quantification to the algebra of its component parts
[Fine,K]
|
15594
|
'Instantial' accounts of variables say we grasp arbitrary instances from their use in quantification
[Fine,K]
|
15596
|
The standard aim of semantics is to assign a semantic value to each expression
[Fine,K]
|
15598
|
We should pursue semantic facts as stated by truths in theories (and not put the theories first!)
[Fine,K]
|
15599
|
Cicero/Cicero and Cicero/Tully may differ in relationship, despite being semantically the same
[Fine,K]
|
15600
|
Referentialist semantics has objects for names, properties for predicates, and propositions for connectives
[Fine,K]
|
15601
|
Fregeans approach the world through sense, Referentialists through reference
[Fine,K]
|
15603
|
I can only represent individuals as the same if I do not already represent them as the same
[Fine,K]
|
15604
|
If Cicero=Tully refers to the man twice, then surely Cicero=Cicero does as well?
[Fine,K]
|
15602
|
Mental files are devices for keeping track of basic coordination of objects
[Fine,K]
|
15605
|
I take indexicals such as 'this' and 'that' to be linked to some associated demonstration
[Fine,K]
|