more on this theme
|
more from this thinker
Single Idea 16180
[filed under theme 14. Science / D. Explanation / 2. Types of Explanation / e. Lawlike explanations
]
Full Idea
'Why does that quail in the garden bob its head up and down in that funny way whenever it walks?' …'Because they all do'.
Gist of Idea
You can't explain one quail's behaviour by just saying that all quails do it
Source
Nancy Cartwright (How the Laws of Physics Lie [1983], 3.5)
Book Ref
Cartwright,Nancy: 'How the Laws of Physics Lie' [OUP 2002], p.70
A Reaction
She cites this as an old complaint against the covering-law model of explanation. It captures beautifully the basic error of the approach. We want to know 'why', rather than just have a description of the pattern. 'They all do' is useful information.
The
17 ideas
from 'How the Laws of Physics Lie'
6781
|
There are fundamental explanatory laws (false!), and phenomenological laws (regularities)
[Cartwright,N, by Bird]
|
16166
|
Laws of appearances are 'phenomenological'; laws of reality are 'theoretical'
[Cartwright,N]
|
16170
|
To get from facts to equations, we need a prepared descriptions suited to mathematics
[Cartwright,N]
|
16167
|
Laws get the facts wrong, and explanation rests on improvements and qualifications of laws
[Cartwright,N]
|
16169
|
Laws apply to separate domains, but real explanations apply to intersecting domains
[Cartwright,N]
|
16171
|
The covering law view assumes that each phenomenon has a 'right' explanation
[Cartwright,N]
|
16175
|
A cause won't increase the effect frequency if other causes keep interfering
[Cartwright,N]
|
16176
|
Covering-law explanation lets us explain storms by falling barometers
[Cartwright,N]
|
16177
|
I disagree with the covering-law view that there is a law to cover every single case
[Cartwright,N]
|
16178
|
There are few laws for when one theory meets another
[Cartwright,N]
|
16179
|
Good organisation may not be true, and the truth may not organise very much
[Cartwright,N]
|
16180
|
You can't explain one quail's behaviour by just saying that all quails do it
[Cartwright,N]
|
16181
|
Simple laws have quite different outcomes when they act in combinations
[Cartwright,N]
|
16182
|
Two main types of explanation are by causes, or by citing a theoretical framework
[Cartwright,N]
|
16183
|
In science, best explanations have regularly turned out to be false
[Cartwright,N]
|
16184
|
An explanation is a model that fits a theory and predicts the phenomenological laws
[Cartwright,N]
|
16185
|
Causality indicates which properties are real
[Cartwright,N]
|