more on this theme
|
more from this thinker
Single Idea 17981
[filed under theme 18. Thought / D. Concepts / 4. Structure of Concepts / e. Concepts from exemplars
]
Full Idea
The findings showing that children use knowledge and may be essentialist about category membership do not comport well with the exemplar view.
Gist of Idea
Children using knowing and essentialist categories doesn't fit the exemplar view
Source
Gregory L. Murphy (The Big Book of Concepts [2004], Ch.13)
Book Ref
Murphy,Gregory L.: 'The Big Book of Concepts' [MIT 2004], p.485
A Reaction
Tricky, because Gelman persuaded me of the essentialism, but the exemplar view of concepts looks the most promising. Clearly they must be forced to coexist....
Related Ideas
Idea 17980
The main theories of concepts are exemplar, prototype and knowledge [Murphy]
Idea 17977
The exemplar view of concepts says 'dogs' is the set of dogs I remember [Murphy]
Idea 17982
Exemplar theory struggles with hierarchical classification and with induction [Murphy]
The
24 ideas
from 'The Big Book of Concepts'
17973
|
The theoretical and practical definitions for the classical view are very hard to find
[Murphy]
|
17969
|
The classical definitional approach cannot distinguish typical and atypical category members
[Murphy]
|
17970
|
Classical concepts follow classical logic, but concepts in real life don't work that way
[Murphy]
|
17971
|
Classical concepts are transitive hierarchies, but actual categories may be intransitive
[Murphy]
|
17972
|
The classical core is meant to be the real concept, but actually seems unimportant
[Murphy]
|
17974
|
The most popular theories of concepts are based on prototypes or exemplars
[Murphy]
|
17977
|
The exemplar view of concepts says 'dogs' is the set of dogs I remember
[Murphy]
|
17978
|
We do not learn concepts in isolation, but as an integrated part of broader knowledge
[Murphy]
|
17975
|
There is no 'ideal' bird or dog, and prototypes give no information about variability
[Murphy]
|
17976
|
Prototypes are unified representations of the entire category (rather than of members)
[Murphy]
|
18691
|
The prototype theory uses observed features, but can't include their construction
[Murphy]
|
18687
|
Concepts with familiar contents are easier to learn
[Murphy]
|
18688
|
Some knowledge is involved in instant use of categories, other knowledge in explanations
[Murphy]
|
18689
|
People categorise things consistent with their knowledge, even rejecting some good evidence
[Murphy]
|
18690
|
Induction is said to just compare properties of categories, but the type of property also matters
[Murphy]
|
17980
|
The main theories of concepts are exemplar, prototype and knowledge
[Murphy]
|
17979
|
Research shows perceptual discrimination is sharper at category boundaries
[Murphy]
|
17982
|
Exemplar theory struggles with hierarchical classification and with induction
[Murphy]
|
17981
|
Children using knowing and essentialist categories doesn't fit the exemplar view
[Murphy]
|
17984
|
Conceptual combination must be compositional, and can't be built up from exemplars
[Murphy]
|
17987
|
The concept of birds from exemplars must also be used in inductions about birds
[Murphy]
|
17983
|
The prototype theory handles hierarchical categories and combinations of concepts well
[Murphy]
|
17985
|
Prototypes theory of concepts is best, as a full description with weighted typical features
[Murphy]
|
17986
|
Learning concepts is forming prototypes with a knowledge structure
[Murphy]
|