more from this thinker     |     more from this text

Single Idea 18145

[filed under theme 6. Mathematics / B. Foundations for Mathematics / 5. Definitions of Number / d. Hume's Principle ]

Full Idea

Hume's Principle gives a criterion of identity for numbers, but it is obvious that many other things satisfy that criterion. The simplest example is probably the numerals (in any notation, decimal, binary etc.), giving many different interpretations.

Gist of Idea

Many things will satisfy Hume's Principle, so there are many interpretations of it

Source

David Bostock (Philosophy of Mathematics [2009], 9.A.2)

Book Ref

Bostock,David: 'Philosophy of Mathematics: An Introduction' [Wiley-Blackwell 2009], p.271

Related Ideas

Idea 18146 If Hume's Principle is the whole story, that implies structuralism [Bostock]

Idea 18147 Neo-logicists meet the Caesar problem by saying Hume's Principle is unique to number [Bostock]

The 19 ideas with the same theme [view that one-one correspondence is basis of numbers]:

8649 Two numbers are equal if all of their units correspond to one another [Hume]
9956 'The number of Fs' is the extension (a collection of first-level concepts) of the concept 'equinumerous with F' [Frege, by George/Velleman]
13527 Frege's cardinals (equivalences of one-one correspondences) is not permissible in ZFC [Frege, by Wolf,RS]
22292 Hume's Principle fails to implicitly define numbers, because of the Julius Caesar [Frege, by Potter]
17442 Frege thinks number is fundamentally bound up with one-one correspondence [Frege, by Heck]
14425 A number is something which characterises collections of the same size [Russell]
18145 Many things will satisfy Hume's Principle, so there are many interpretations of it [Bostock]
18149 There are many criteria for the identity of numbers [Bostock]
18148 Hume's Principle is a definition with existential claims, and won't explain numbers [Bostock]
10140 We derive Hume's Law from Law V, then discard the latter in deriving arithmetic [Wright,C, by Fine,K]
8692 Frege has a good system if his 'number principle' replaces his basic law V [Wright,C, by Friend]
17440 Wright says Hume's Principle is analytic of cardinal numbers, like a definition [Wright,C, by Heck]
13893 It is 1-1 correlation of concepts, and not progression, which distinguishes natural number [Wright,C]
8784 Neo-logicism founds arithmetic on Hume's Principle along with second-order logic [Hale/Wright]
10529 If Hume's Principle can define numbers, we needn't worry about its truth [Fine,K]
10530 Hume's Principle is either adequate for number but fails to define properly, or vice versa [Fine,K]
8266 Simple counting is more basic than spotting that one-to-one correlation makes sets equinumerous [Lowe]
8302 Fs and Gs are identical in number if they one-to-one correlate with one another [Lowe]
10133 Frege's Theorem shows the Peano Postulates can be derived from Hume's Principle [George/Velleman]