more from this thinker
|
more from this text
Single Idea 19509
[filed under theme 13. Knowledge Criteria / C. External Justification / 6. Contextual Justification / a. Contextualism
]
Full Idea
One might have a 'hidden-indexical' theory of knowledge sentences: they contain constituents that are not the semantic values of any terms; ...or 'to know' itself might be indexical, as in 'I know[easy] I have hands' or 'I know[tough] I have hands'.
Gist of Idea
The indexical aspect of contextual knowledge might be hidden, or it might be in what 'know' means
Source
Stephen Schiffer (Contextualist Solutions to Scepticism [1996], p.326-7), quoted by Keith DeRose - The Case for Contextualism 1.5
Book Ref
DeRose,Keith: 'The Case for Contextualism' [OUP 2009], p.10
A Reaction
[very compressed] Given the choice, I would have thought it was in 'know', since to say 'either you know p or you don't' sounds silly to me.
Related Idea
Idea 19508
Contextualism needs a semantics for knowledge sentences that are partly indexical [Schiffer,S]
The
18 ideas
with the same theme
[defence of context as vital to knowledge claims]:
12895
|
Knowing is context-sensitive because the domain of quantification varies
[Lewis, by Cohen,S]
|
19562
|
We have knowledge if alternatives are eliminated, but appropriate alternatives depend on context
[Lewis, by Cohen,S]
|
9166
|
People vary in their epistemological standards, and none of them is 'correct'
[Field,H]
|
19558
|
Our own intuitions about whether we know tend to vacillate
[Cohen,S]
|
19561
|
We shouldn't jump too quickly to a contextualist account of claims to know
[Cohen,S]
|
19563
|
The context sensitivity of knowledge derives from its justification
[Cohen,S]
|
19560
|
Contextualism is good because it allows knowledge, but bad because 'knowing' is less valued
[Cohen,S]
|
12893
|
Contextualism says sceptical arguments are true, relative to their strict context
[Cohen,S]
|
12896
|
Knowledge is context-sensitive, because justification is
[Cohen,S]
|
19514
|
Classical invariantism combines fixed truth-conditions with variable assertability standards
[DeRose]
|
19515
|
We can make contextualism more precise, by specifying the discrimination needed each time
[DeRose]
|
19510
|
In some contexts there is little more to knowledge than true belief.
[DeRose]
|
19516
|
Contextualists worry about scepticism, but they should focus on the use of 'know' in ordinary speech
[DeRose]
|
10341
|
Justification depends on the audience and one's social role
[Kusch]
|
6597
|
A rule of justification might be: don't raise the level of scrutiny without a good reason
[Fogelin]
|
19555
|
People begin to doubt whether they 'know' when the answer becomes more significant
[Conee]
|
19508
|
Contextualism needs a semantics for knowledge sentences that are partly indexical
[Schiffer,S]
|
19509
|
The indexical aspect of contextual knowledge might be hidden, or it might be in what 'know' means
[Schiffer,S]
|