more from this thinker | more from this text
Full Idea
There has been a tendency to treat fallibilism as an alternative to either dogmatism or scepticism. ...But it is much better to think of fallibilism as consistent with either dogmatism or skepticism.
Gist of Idea
Fallibilism is consistent with dogmatism or scepticism, and is not alternative to them
Source
Trent Dougherty (Fallibilism [2011], 'Closure')
Book Ref
'Routledge Companion to Epistemology', ed/tr. Bernecker,S/Pritchard,D [Routledge 2014], p.137
A Reaction
It seems perfectly reasonably to describe oneself as a 'fallibilist dogmatist' (perhaps from the Pope?), or a 'fallibilist sceptic' (perhaps from Peter Unger?), so this idea sounds correct.
12569 | Knowledge by senses is less certain than that by intuition or reason, but it is still knowledge [Locke] |
14768 | Infallibility in science is just a joke [Peirce] |
14770 | Reasoning is based on statistical induction, so it can't achieve certainty or precision [Peirce] |
19107 | Inquiry is not standing on bedrock facts, but standing in hope on a shifting bog [Peirce] |
22870 | No belief can be so settled that it is not subject to further inquiry [Dewey] |
17637 | The most obvious beliefs are not infallible, as other obvious beliefs may conflict [Russell] |
12897 | To say S knows P, but cannot eliminate not-P, sounds like a contradiction [Lewis] |
2755 | If senses are fallible, then being open to correction is an epistemological virtue [Dancy,J] |
6898 | Fallibilism is the view that all knowledge-claims are provisional [Mautner] |
19701 | Fallibilism is consistent with dogmatism or scepticism, and is not alternative to them [Dougherty] |
19700 | It is best to see the fallibility in the reasons, rather than in the agents or the knowledge [Dougherty] |
19702 | We can't normally say that we know something 'but it might be false' [Dougherty] |
19718 | Indefeasibility does not imply infallibility [Grundmann] |