more on this theme     |     more from this text

Single Idea 20332

[filed under theme 21. Aesthetics / C. Artistic Issues / 3. Artistic Representation ]

Full Idea

It is necessary, if a drawing is to represent Napoleon, that the draughtsman should intend it to be Napoleon.

Gist of Idea

A drawing only represents Napoleon if the artist intended it to

Source

Richard Wollheim (Art and Its Objects [1968], 13)

Book Ref

Wollheim,Richard: 'Art and Its Objects' [Penguin 1975], p.34

A Reaction

Does a perfect and intended representation of a person also count as a representation of the person's identical twin? The families of both might well order copies.

The 16 ideas from Richard Wollheim

20331 It is claimed that the expressive properties of artworks are non-physical [Wollheim]
20332 A drawing only represents Napoleon if the artist intended it to [Wollheim]
20333 If artworks are not physical objects, they are either ideal entities, or collections of phenomena [Wollheim]
20334 The ideal theory says art is an intuition, shaped by a particular process, and presented in public [Wollheim]
20335 The ideal theory of art neglects both the audience and the medium employed [Wollheim]
20336 Style can't be seen directly within a work, but appreciation needs a grasp of style [Wollheim]
20337 The traditional view is that knowledge of its genre to essential to appreciating literature [Wollheim]
20338 We often treat a type as if it were a sort of token [Wollheim]
20341 An interpretation adds further properties to the generic piece of music [Wollheim]
20340 A musical performance has virtually the same features as the piece of music [Wollheim]
20342 Interpretation is performance for some arts, and critical for all arts [Wollheim]
20343 A love of nature must precede a love of art [Wollheim]
20345 Some say art must have verbalisable expression, and others say the opposite! [Wollheim]
20347 If beauty needs organisation, then totally simple things can't be beautiful [Wollheim]
20348 A criterion of identity for works of art would be easier than a definition [Wollheim]
20339 Classes rarely share properties with their members - unlike universals and types [Wollheim]