more on this theme
|
more from this text
Single Idea 20340
[filed under theme 21. Aesthetics / B. Nature of Art / 7. Ontology of Art
]
Full Idea
With the usual reservations, there is nothing that can be predicated of a performance of a piece of music that could not also be predicated of that piece of music itself.
Gist of Idea
A musical performance has virtually the same features as the piece of music
Source
Richard Wollheim (Art and Its Objects [1968], 37)
Book Ref
Wollheim,Richard: 'Art and Its Objects' [Penguin 1975], p.97
A Reaction
He offers this as evidence that it fits the performance being a token, and music (and all other art) being a type. There are quite a few 'reservations'. Music too difficult to perform. Great music always badly performed.
The
16 ideas
from Richard Wollheim
20331
|
It is claimed that the expressive properties of artworks are non-physical
[Wollheim]
|
20332
|
A drawing only represents Napoleon if the artist intended it to
[Wollheim]
|
20333
|
If artworks are not physical objects, they are either ideal entities, or collections of phenomena
[Wollheim]
|
20334
|
The ideal theory says art is an intuition, shaped by a particular process, and presented in public
[Wollheim]
|
20335
|
The ideal theory of art neglects both the audience and the medium employed
[Wollheim]
|
20336
|
Style can't be seen directly within a work, but appreciation needs a grasp of style
[Wollheim]
|
20337
|
The traditional view is that knowledge of its genre to essential to appreciating literature
[Wollheim]
|
20338
|
We often treat a type as if it were a sort of token
[Wollheim]
|
20341
|
An interpretation adds further properties to the generic piece of music
[Wollheim]
|
20340
|
A musical performance has virtually the same features as the piece of music
[Wollheim]
|
20342
|
Interpretation is performance for some arts, and critical for all arts
[Wollheim]
|
20343
|
A love of nature must precede a love of art
[Wollheim]
|
20345
|
Some say art must have verbalisable expression, and others say the opposite!
[Wollheim]
|
20347
|
If beauty needs organisation, then totally simple things can't be beautiful
[Wollheim]
|
20348
|
A criterion of identity for works of art would be easier than a definition
[Wollheim]
|
20339
|
Classes rarely share properties with their members - unlike universals and types
[Wollheim]
|