more from this thinker     |     more from this text

Single Idea 21334

[filed under theme 29. Religion / D. Religious Issues / 3. Problem of Evil / a. Problem of Evil ]

Full Idea

If a Creator is assumed to be omnipotent, if he bends to a supposed necessity, he himself makes the necessity which he bends to. If the maker of the world can all that he will, he wills misery, and there is no escape from the conclusion.

Gist of Idea

No necessity ties an omnipotent Creator, so he evidently wills human misery

Source

John Stuart Mill (Nature and Utility of Religion [1874], p.119)

Book Ref

'The Existence of God', ed/tr. Hick,John [Macmillan 1964], p.119

A Reaction

If you add that the Creator is supposed to be perfectly benevolent, you arrive at the paradox which Mackie spells out. Is the correct conclusion that God exists, and is malevolent? Mill doesn't take that option seriously.

The 21 ideas with the same theme [reasons for the existence of evil]:

2057 There must always be some force of evil ranged against good [Plato]
2659 The lists of good men who have suffered and bad men who have prospered are endless [Cicero]
20698 Irenaeus says evil is necessary for perfect human development [Irenaeus, by Davies,B]
5761 God can do anything, but he cannot do evil, so evil must be nothing [Boethius]
5766 If you could see the plan of Providence, you would not think there was evil anywhere [Boethius]
21266 God does not exist, because He is infinite and good, and so no evil should be discoverable [Aquinas]
21274 It is part of God's supreme goodness that He brings good even out of evil [Aquinas]
19339 Evil is a negation of good, which arises from non-being [Leibniz]
13164 God only made sin possible because a much greater good can be derived from it [Leibniz]
19337 How can an all-good, wise and powerful being allow evil, sin and apparent injustice? [Leibniz]
19345 Being confident of God's goodness, we disregard the apparent local evils in the visible world [Leibniz]
6737 Particular evils are really good when linked to the whole system of beings [Berkeley]
21468 The Creator created the possibilities for worlds, so should have made a better one than this possible [Schopenhauer]
21335 Belief that an afterlife is required for justice is an admission that this life is very unjust [Mill]
21333 Evil comes from good just as often as good comes from evil [Mill]
21334 No necessity ties an omnipotent Creator, so he evidently wills human misery [Mill]
7200 A combination of great power and goodness would mean the disastrous abolition of evil [Nietzsche]
1473 Is evil an illusion, or a necessary contrast, or uncontrollable, or necessary for human free will? [Mackie, by PG]
1472 The propositions that God is good and omnipotent, and that evil exists, are logically contradictory [Mackie, by PG]
2175 There is a problem of evil only if you expect the world to be good [Williams,B]
24164 Even non-theists can wonder what, if anything, makes the universe good [Cochrane]