more from this thinker     |     more from this text

Single Idea 22293

[filed under theme 6. Mathematics / C. Sources of Mathematics / 7. Formalism ]

Full Idea

Hilbert proposed to circuvent the paradoxes by means of the doctrine (already proposed by Poincaré) that in mathematics consistency entails existence.

Gist of Idea

Hilbert said (to block paradoxes) that mathematical existence is entailed by consistency

Source

report of David Hilbert (On the Concept of Number [1900], p.183) by Michael Potter - The Rise of Analytic Philosophy 1879-1930 19 'Exist'

Book Ref

Potter,Michael: 'The Rise of Anaytic Philosophy 1879-1930' [Routledge 2020], p.129

A Reaction

Interesting. Hilbert's idea has struck me as weird, but it makes sense if its main motive is to block the paradoxes. Roughly, the idea is 'it exists if it isn't paradoxical'. A low bar for existence (but then it is only in mathematics!).

The 24 ideas with the same theme [maths is the consequences of a set of symbols]:

9887 Formalism misunderstands applications, metatheory, and infinity [Frege, by Dummett]
8751 Only applicability raises arithmetic from a game to a science [Frege]
9631 Formalism fails to recognise types of symbols, and also meta-games [Frege, by Brown,JR]
22293 Hilbert said (to block paradoxes) that mathematical existence is entailed by consistency [Hilbert, by Potter]
12459 The subject matter of mathematics is immediate and clear concrete symbols [Hilbert]
10113 The grounding of mathematics is 'in the beginning was the sign' [Hilbert]
10115 Hilbert substituted a syntactic for a semantic account of consistency [Hilbert, by George/Velleman]
21570 Numbers are just verbal conveniences, which can be analysed away [Russell]
6424 Formalists say maths is merely conventional marks on paper, like the arbitrary rules of chess [Russell]
6425 Formalism can't apply numbers to reality, so it is an evasion [Russell]
13425 Formalism is hopeless, because it focuses on propositions and ignores concepts [Ramsey]
10154 Tarski's theory of truth shifted the approach away from syntax, to set theory and semantics [Feferman/Feferman on Tarski]
1616 Formalism says maths is built of meaningless notations; these build into rules which have meaning [Quine]
10062 Formalism seems to exclude all creative, growing mathematics [Musgrave]
10063 Formalism is a bulwark of logical positivism [Musgrave]
8749 Term Formalism says mathematics is just about symbols - but real numbers have no names [Shapiro]
8750 Game Formalism is just a matter of rules, like chess - but then why is it useful in science? [Shapiro]
8752 Deductivism says mathematics is logical consequences of uninterpreted axioms [Shapiro]
9629 For nomalists there are no numbers, only numerals [Brown,JR]
9630 The most brilliant formalist was Hilbert [Brown,JR]
9639 Does some mathematics depend entirely on notation? [Brown,JR]
22310 The formalist defence against Gödel is to reject his metalinguistic concept of truth [Potter]
23442 Game Formalism has no semantics, and Term Formalism reduces the semantics [Linnebo]
8716 Formalism is unconstrained, so cannot indicate importance, or directions for research [Friend]