more on this theme
|
more from this text
Single Idea 23921
[filed under theme 21. Aesthetics / A. Aesthetic Experience / 5. Natural Beauty
]
Full Idea
It is not what I call an aesthetic emotion that most of us feel, generally, for natural beauty. …Most people feel a very different kind of emotion for birds, flowers and butterfly wings from that we feel for pictures, pots, temples and statues.
Gist of Idea
Our feeling for natural beauty is different from the aesthetic emotion of art
Source
Clive Bell (Art [1913], I.I)
Book Ref
Bell,Clive: 'Art' [nk 2010], p.5
A Reaction
Not convinced. I think the main difference is our awareness that art is a human production, the result of choice, whereas nature is a given. Beethoven 9 and a good sunset don't seem to me far apart in our responses.
The
18 ideas
from Clive Bell
|
8115
|
Only artists can discern significant form; other people must look to art to find it
[Bell,C, by Gardner]
|
|
23922
|
The word 'beauty' leads to confusion, because it denotes distinct emotions
[Bell,C]
|
|
23921
|
Our feeling for natural beauty is different from the aesthetic emotion of art
[Bell,C]
|
|
23923
|
Visual form can create a sublime mental state
[Bell,C]
|
|
23925
|
Mere copies of pictures are not significant - unless the copies are very exact
[Bell,C]
|
|
23926
|
Art is distinguished by its aesthetic emotion, which produces appropriate form
[Bell,C]
|
|
23927
|
Aestheticism invites artist to create beauty, but with no indication of how to do it
[Bell,C]
|
|
23928
|
Good art produces exaltation and detachment
[Bell,C]
|
|
23924
|
Maybe significant form gives us a feeling for ultimate reality
[Bell,C]
|
|
23929
|
We only see landscapes as artistic if we ignore their instrumental value
[Bell,C]
|
|
23930
|
Religion sees infinite value in some things, and irrelevance in the rest
[Bell,C]
|
|
23931
|
Significant form is the essence of art, which I believe expresses an emotion about reality
[Bell,C]
|
|
23932
|
Art is the expression of an emotion for ultimate reality
[Bell,C]
|
|
22691
|
Only artistic qualities matter in art, because they also have the highest moral value
[Bell,C]
|
|
23933
|
Aesthetic contemplation is the best and most intense mental state
[Bell,C]
|
|
23934
|
The only expression art could have is the emotion resulting from pure form
[Bell,C]
|
|
23935
|
Aesthetic experience is an exaltation which increases the possibilities of life
[Bell,C]
|
|
20434
|
'Form' is visual relations, and it is 'significant' if it moves us aesthetically; art needs both
[Bell,C, by Feagin]
|