more on this theme | more from this thinker
Full Idea
It seems to me now that syntax is not intrinsic to the physics of the system, but is in the eye of the beholder.
Clarification
Syntax is sentence structure (where 'semantics' is meaning)
Gist of Idea
I now think syntax is not in the physics, but in the eye of the beholder
Source
John Searle (The Mystery of Consciousness [1997], Ch.1)
Book Ref
Searle,John R.: 'The Mystery of Consciousness' [Granta 1997], p.14
A Reaction
This seems right, in that whether strung beads are a toy or an abacus depends on the user. It doesn't follow that the 'beholder' stands outside the physics. A beholder is another physical system, of a particular type of high complexity.
5790 | A property is 'emergent' if it is caused by elements of a system, when the elements lack the property [Searle] |
5786 | A system is either conscious or it isn't, though the intensity varies a lot [Searle] |
5788 | The use of 'qualia' seems to imply that consciousness and qualia are separate [Searle] |
5789 | I now think syntax is not in the physics, but in the eye of the beholder [Searle] |
5787 | There is non-event causation between mind and brain, as between a table and its solidity [Searle] |
5792 | Explanation of how we unify our mental stimuli into a single experience is the 'binding problem' [Searle] |
5791 | Reduction is either by elimination, or by explanation [Searle] |
5794 | Consciousness has a first-person ontology, which only exists from a subjective viewpoint [Searle] |
5798 | Consciousness has a first-person ontology, so it cannot be reduced without omitting something [Searle] |
5799 | Eliminative reduction needs a gap between appearance and reality, as in sunsets [Searle] |
5796 | If tree rings contain information about age, then age contains information about rings [Searle] |
5797 | The pattern of molecules in the sea is much more complex than the complexity of brain neurons [Searle] |
5795 | There isn't one consciousness (information-processing) which can be investigated, and another (phenomenal) which can't [Searle] |