more on this theme | more from this thinker
Full Idea
It is doubtful whether the subject-predicate logic, with the substance-attribute metaphysic, would have been invented by people speaking a non-Aryan language.
Clarification
Most European languages (e.g. Greek) are 'Aryan'
Gist of Idea
Subject-predicate logic (and substance-attribute metaphysics) arise from Aryan languages
Source
Bertrand Russell (Logical Atomism [1924], p.151)
Book Ref
Russell,Bertrand: 'Russell's Logical Atomism', ed/tr. Pears,David [Fontana 1972], p.151
A Reaction
This is not far off the Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis (e.g. Idea 3917), which Russell would never accept. I presume that Russell would see true logic as running deeper, and the 'Aryan' approach as just one possible way to describe it.
Related Idea
Idea 3917 Scientific thought is essentially a specialised part of Indo-European languages [Whorf]
| 10968 | Russell gave up logical atomism because of negative, general and belief propositions [Russell, by Read] |
| 6107 | It is logic, not metaphysics, that is fundamental to philosophy [Russell] |
| 6109 | Some axioms may only become accepted when they lead to obvious conclusions [Russell] |
| 6108 | Maths can be deduced from logical axioms and the logic of relations [Russell] |
| 6110 | Subject-predicate logic (and substance-attribute metaphysics) arise from Aryan languages [Russell] |
| 6111 | As propositions can be put in subject-predicate form, we wrongly infer that facts have substance-quality form [Russell] |
| 6112 | Meaning takes many different forms, depending on different logical types [Russell] |
| 6113 | To mean facts we assert them; to mean simples we name them [Russell] |
| 6114 | 'Simples' are not experienced, but are inferred at the limits of analysis [Russell] |
| 6116 | A logical language would show up the fallacy of inferring reality from ordinary language [Russell] |
| 6115 | Vagueness, and simples being beyond experience, are obstacles to a logical language [Russell] |
| 6117 | Philosophy should be built on science, to reduce error [Russell] |
| 21722 | Better to construct from what is known, than to infer what is unknown [Russell] |
| 6118 | Philosophy is logical analysis, followed by synthesis [Russell] |