more on this theme
|
more from this text
Single Idea 6414
[filed under theme 12. Knowledge Sources / A. A Priori Knowledge / 2. Self-Evidence
]
Full Idea
Two propositions might contradict each other despite appearing self-evident when considered separately.
Gist of Idea
Two propositions might seem self-evident, but contradict one another
Source
A.C. Grayling (Russell [1996], Ch.2)
Book Ref
Grayling,A.C.: 'Russell' [OUP 1996], p.42
A Reaction
Russell's proposal (Idea 5416) is important here, that self-evidence comes in degrees. If self-evidence was all-or-nothing, Grayling's point would be a major problem, but it isn't. Bonjour explores the idea more fully (e.g. Idea 3704)
Related Ideas
Idea 3704
Moderate rationalists believe in fallible a priori justification [Bonjour]
Idea 5416
If self-evidence has degrees, we should accept the more self-evident as correct [Russell]
The
20 ideas
from A.C. Grayling
7293
|
It is legitimate to do harm if it is the unintended side-effect of an effort to achieve a good
[Grayling]
|
7292
|
War must also have a good chance of success, and be waged with moderation
[Grayling]
|
6408
|
Russell needed three extra axioms to reduce maths to logic: infinity, choice and reducibility
[Grayling]
|
6414
|
Two propositions might seem self-evident, but contradict one another
[Grayling]
|
23253
|
Majority decisions are only acceptable if the minority interests are not vital
[Grayling]
|
23256
|
Liberty and equality cannot be reconciled
[Grayling]
|
23258
|
The very concept of democracy entails a need for justice
[Grayling]
|
23259
|
There should be separate legislative, executive and judicial institutions
[Grayling]
|
23260
|
A cap on time of service would restrict party control and career ambitions
[Grayling]
|
23262
|
Experience, sympathy and history are sensible grounds for laying claim to rights
[Grayling]
|
23263
|
Politics is driven by power cliques
[Grayling]
|
23254
|
Democracies should require a supermajority for major questions
[Grayling]
|
23255
|
It is essential for democracy that voting is free and well informed
[Grayling]
|
7809
|
In an honour code shame is the supreme punishment, and revenge is a duty
[Grayling]
|
7818
|
In Greek mythology only heroes can go to heaven
[Grayling]
|
7819
|
Religion gives answers, comforts, creates social order, and panders to superstition
[Grayling]
|
7817
|
To make an afterlife appealing, this life has to be denigrated
[Grayling]
|
7823
|
Lucretius was rediscovered in 1417
[Grayling]
|
7824
|
If suicide is lawful, but assisting suicide is unlawful, powerless people are denied their rights
[Grayling]
|
7091
|
The argument from analogy is not a strong inference, since the other being might be an actor or a robot
[Grayling]
|