more on this theme     |     more from this text

Single Idea 7957

[filed under theme 8. Modes of Existence / E. Nominalism / 2. Resemblance Nominalism ]

Full Idea

Goodman's 'imperfect community' problem for Resemblance Nominalism says that without mention of respects in which things resemble, we end up with a heterogeneous collection with nothing wholly in common (blue book, blue pen, red pen, red clock).

Clarification

'Heterogeneous' means all different

Gist of Idea

Without respects of resemblance, we would collect blue book, blue pen, red pen, red clock together

Source

report of Nelson Goodman (The Structure of Appearance [1951]) by Cynthia Macdonald - Varieties of Things Ch.6

Book Ref

Macdonald,Cynthia: 'Varieties of Things' [Blackwell 2005], p.231

A Reaction

This suggests Wittgenstein's 'family' resemblance as a way out (Idea 4141), but a blue book and a red clock seem totally unrelated. Nice objection! At this point we start to think that the tropes resemble, rather than the objects.

Related Idea

Idea 4141 Various games have a 'family resemblance', as their similarities overlap and criss-cross [Wittgenstein]

The 30 ideas from Nelson Goodman

18749 Goodman argued that the confirmation relation can never be formalised [Goodman, by Horsten/Pettigrew]
17646 Goodman showed that every sound inductive argument has an unsound one of the same form [Goodman, by Putnam]
14292 Dispositions seem more ethereal than behaviour; a non-occult account of them would be nice [Goodman]
4794 We don't use laws to make predictions, we call things laws if we make predictions with them [Goodman]
12394 If the result is bad, we change the rule; if we like the rule, we reject the result [Goodman]
8113 Art is like understanding a natural language, and needs a grasp of a symbol system [Goodman, by Gardner]
20439 Artistic symbols are judged by the fruitfulness of their classifications [Goodman, by Giovannelli]
20438 A performance is only an instance of a work if there is not a single error [Goodman]
20437 A copy only becomes an 'instance' of an artwork if there is a system of notation [Goodman]
20440 Art is a referential activity, hence indefinable, but it has a set of symptoms [Goodman]
12191 Counterfactuals are true if logical or natural laws imply the consequence [Goodman, by McFetridge]
7956 If all and only red things were round things, we would need to specify the 'respect' of the resemblance [Goodman, by Macdonald,C]
7957 Without respects of resemblance, we would collect blue book, blue pen, red pen, red clock together [Goodman, by Macdonald,C]
9920 Two objects can apparently make up quite distinct arrangements in sets [Goodman, by Burgess/Rosen]
7952 If we apply the same word to different things, it is only because we are willing to do so [Goodman, by Macdonald,C]
15510 Classes are a host of ethereal, platonic, pseudo entities [Goodman]
10657 The counties of Utah, and the state, and its acres, are in no way different [Goodman]
17649 If the world is one it has many aspects, and if there are many worlds they will collect into one [Goodman]
17650 We lack frames of reference to transform physics, biology and psychology into one another [Goodman]
17651 Without words or other symbols, we have no world [Goodman]
17654 A world can be full of variety or not, depending on how we sort it [Goodman]
17653 Things can only be judged the 'same' by citing some respect of sameness [Goodman]
17655 Grue and green won't be in the same world, as that would block induction entirely [Goodman]
17656 Being primitive or prior always depends on a constructional system [Goodman]
17657 We build our world, and ignore anything that won't fit [Goodman]
17658 Users of digital thermometers recognise no temperatures in the gaps [Goodman]
17652 Truth is irrelevant if no statements are involved [Goodman]
17659 Reality is largely a matter of habit [Goodman]
17661 We don't recognise patterns - we invent them [Goodman]
17660 Discovery is often just finding a fit, like a jigsaw puzzle [Goodman]