more from this thinker     |     more from this text

Single Idea 4807

[filed under theme 14. Science / A. Basis of Science / 4. Prediction ]

Full Idea

There can be predictions without explanations, as when a barometer successfully predicts storms, but on its own it does not explain them.

Gist of Idea

A good barometer will predict a storm, but not explain it

Source

Stathis Psillos (Causation and Explanation [2002], §8.8)

Book Ref

Psillos,Stathis: 'Causation and Explanation' [Acumen 2002], p.236

A Reaction

Actually, barometers contribute to explanations. A reasonable predictor might offer no explanation ('if he's out, she's probably out too'), but an infallible predictor is almost certain to involve causation, which helps a lot in explanation.

The 18 ideas with the same theme [predicting events as support for a theory]:

12738 Successful prediction shows proficiency in nature [Leibniz]
22179 Explanatory facts also predict, and predictive facts also explain [Hempel, by Okasha]
13054 Correlations can provide predictions, but only causes can give explanations [Salmon]
18960 Most predictions are uninteresting, and are only sought in order to confirm a theory [Putnam]
8057 Unpredictability doesn't entail inexplicability, and predictability doesn't entail explicability [MacIntyre]
17087 The 'symmetry thesis' says explanation and prediction only differ pragmatically [Ruben]
16856 It is more impressive that relativity predicted Mercury's orbit than if it had accommodated it [Lipton]
16857 Predictions are best for finding explanations, because mere accommodations can be fudged [Lipton]
5340 Explanation does not entail prediction [Flanagan]
17374 The possibility of prediction rests on determinism [Dupré]
4807 A good barometer will predict a storm, but not explain it [Psillos]
4808 If we say where Mars was two months ago, we offer an explanation without a prediction [Psillos]
6757 Explanation predicts after the event; prediction explains before the event [Bird]
18698 Predictions give the 'content' of theories, which can then be 'equivalent' or 'adequate' [Button]
14915 The theory of evolution was accepted because it explained, not because of its predictions [Ladyman/Ross]
14916 What matters is whether a theory can predict - not whether it actually does so [Ladyman/Ross]
17405 If a theory can be fudged, so can observations [Scerri]
19737 A system can infer the structure of the world by making predictions about it [New Sci.]