more from this thinker | more from this text
Full Idea
Orthodox truthmaker theory (Armstrong's) entails Maximalism (that every true proposition has at least one truthmaker), and Necessitarianism (that the existence of a truthmaker necessitates the truth of its proposition).
Gist of Idea
Orthodox Truthmaker applies to all propositions, and necessitates their truth
Source
Ross P. Cameron (Truthmakers, Realism and Ontology [2008], 'Max and Nec')
Book Ref
'Being: Developments in Contemporary Metaphysics', ed/tr. Le Poidevin,R [CUP 2008], p.107
A Reaction
I think I accept both of these. If you say only some truths have truthmakers, the other truths are then baffling. And how could a truthmaker fail in its job? But that doesn't necessitate the existence of the proposition.
18467 | Truth-making can't be entailment, because truthmakers are portions of reality [Armstrong] |
18468 | Armstrong says truthmakers necessitate their truth, where 'necessitate' is a primitive relation [Armstrong, by MacBride] |
7005 | Something can only have a place in a preferred account of things if it is entailed by the account [Jackson] |
18469 | God might necessitate that something happen, but He is not the truth-maker for it [Smith,B] |
7004 | The view that truth making is entailment is misguided and misleading [Heil] |
18360 | It is assumed that a proposition is necessarily true if its truth-maker exists [David] |
15395 | Give up objects necessitating truths, and say their natures cause the truths? [Cameron] |
18867 | Orthodox Truthmaker applies to all propositions, and necessitates their truth [Cameron] |
18873 | God fixes all the truths of the world by fixing what exists [Cameron] |
18931 | Determinate truths don't need extra truthmakers, just truthmakers that are themselves determinate [Cameron] |
18342 | Most theorists say that truth-makers necessitate their truths [Rami] |