more on this theme     |     more from this text

Single Idea 19754

[filed under theme 25. Social Practice / C. Rights / 4. Property rights ]

Full Idea

Others have spoken of the natural right that everyone has to preserve what belongs to him, without explaining what they mean by 'belonging'.

Gist of Idea

If we have a natural right to property, what exactly does 'belonging to' mean?

Source

Jean-Jacques Rousseau (Discourse on the Origin of Inequality [1754], Pref)

Book Ref

Rousseau,Jean-Jacques: 'The Basic Political Writings', ed/tr. Cress,Donald A. [Hackett 1987], p.38

A Reaction

This is aimed at Locke. What Marxists will challenge is the legitimacy of property ownership, granted by patronage, enclosure, exploitation and conquest. These start as injustices, but that fades after a few generations. Locke has a labour-theory.

The 132 ideas from Jean-Jacques Rousseau

19745 The nature of people is decided by the government and politics of their society [Rousseau]
19854 We all owe labour in return for our keep, and every idle citizen is a thief [Rousseau]
20759 Feelings are prior to intelligence; we should be content to live with our simplest feelings [Rousseau]
19749 In a direct democracy, only the leaders should be able to propose new laws [Rousseau]
19747 Revolutionaries usually confuse liberty with total freedom, and end up with heavier chains [Rousseau]
19748 Plebiscites are bad, because they exclude the leaders from crucial decisions [Rousseau]
19746 Like rich food, liberty can ruin people who are too weak to cope with it [Rousseau]
19775 People must be made dependent before they can be enslaved [Rousseau]
19770 Primitive people simply redressed the evil caused by violence, without thought of punishing [Rousseau]
19761 Men started with too few particular names, but later had too few natural kind names [Rousseau]
19776 Small uninterrupted causes can have big effects [Rousseau]
19774 A savage can steal fruit or a home, but there is no means of achieving obedience [Rousseau]
19756 Humans are less distinguished from other animals by understanding, than by being free agents [Rousseau]
19755 Most human ills are self-inflicted; the simple, solitary, regular natural life is good [Rousseau]
19762 Is language a pre-requisite for society, or might it emerge afterwards? [Rousseau]
19763 I doubt whether a savage person ever complains of life, or considers suicide [Rousseau]
19765 Savages avoid evil because they are calm, and never think of it (not because they know goodness) [Rousseau]
19771 Savage men quietly pursue desires, without the havoc of modern frenzied imagination [Rousseau]
19757 No one would bother to reason, and try to know things, without a desire for enjoyment [Rousseau]
19760 General ideas are purely intellectual; imagining them is immediately particular [Rousseau]
19759 Only words can introduce general ideas into the mind [Rousseau]
19758 Language may aid thinking, but powerful thought was needed to produce language [Rousseau]
19773 Without love, what use is beauty? [Rousseau]
19767 Reason leads to prudent selfishness, which overrules natural compassion [Rousseau]
19769 Rational morality is OK for brainy people, but ordinary life can't rely on that [Rousseau]
19768 The better Golden Rule is 'do good for yourself without harming others' [Rousseau]
19766 The fact that we weep (e.g. in theatres) shows that we are naturally compassionate [Rousseau]
19772 In a state of nature people are much more equal; it is society which increases inequalities [Rousseau]
19789 It is against nature for children to rule old men, fools to rule the wise, and the rich to hog resources [Rousseau]
19787 People accept the right to be commanded, because they themselves wish to command [Rousseau]
19778 Leisure led to envy, inequality, vice and revenge, which we now see in savages [Rousseau]
19779 Primitive man was very gentle [Rousseau]
19780 We seem to have made individual progress since savagery, but actually the species has decayed [Rousseau]
19783 A state of war remains after a conquest, if the losers don't accept the winners [Rousseau]
19777 Persuading other people that some land was 'owned' was the beginning of society [Rousseau]
19782 What else could property arise from, but the labour people add to it? [Rousseau]
19781 Land cultivation led to a general right of ownership, administered justly [Rousseau]
19784 Enslaved peoples often boast of their condition, calling it a state of 'peace' [Rousseau]
19785 If the child of a slave woman is born a slave, then a man is not born a man [Rousseau]
19786 Three stages of the state produce inequalities of wealth, power, and enslavement [Rousseau]
19788 The pleasure of wealth and power is largely seeing others deprived of them [Rousseau]
19754 If we have a natural right to property, what exactly does 'belonging to' mean? [Rousseau]
19750 Writers just propose natural law as the likely useful agreements among people [Rousseau]
19753 Both men and animals are sentient, which should give the latter the right not to be mistreated [Rousseau]
19751 Our two starting principles are concern for self-interest, and compassion for others [Rousseau]
19752 If we should not mistreat humans, it is mainly because of sentience, not rationality [Rousseau]
20567 Rousseau insists that popular sovereignty needs a means of expressing consent [Rousseau, by Oksala]
20501 Rousseau assumes that laws need a people united by custom and tradition [Rousseau, by Wolff,J]
7232 Man is born free, and he is everywhere in chains [Rousseau]
7233 The social order is a sacred right, but based on covenants, not nature [Rousseau]
19790 Force can only dominate if it is seen as a right, and obedience as a duty [Rousseau]
7234 No man has any natural authority over his fellows [Rousseau]
7235 Without freedom of will actions lack moral significance [Rousseau]
19791 Natural mankind is too fragmented for states of peace, or of war and enmity [Rousseau]
7236 War gives no right to inflict more destruction than is necessary for victory [Rousseau]
7238 Minorities only accept majority-voting because of a prior unanimous agreement [Rousseau]
7237 The act of becoming 'a people' is the real foundation of society [Rousseau]
19792 To overcome obstacles, people must unite their forces into a single unified power [Rousseau]
7239 The social pact is the total subjection of individuals to the general will [Rousseau]
19793 We need a protective association which unites forces, but retains individual freedom [Rousseau]
19794 If we all give up all of our rights together to the community, we will always support one another [Rousseau]
7240 To foreign powers a state is seen as a simple individual [Rousseau]
19795 The act of association commits citizens to the state, and the state to its citizens [Rousseau]
19796 Individual citizens still retain a private will, which may be contrary to the general will [Rousseau]
19797 Citizens must ultimately for forced to accept the general will (so freedom is compulsory!) [Rousseau]
7241 In society man loses natural liberty, but gains a right to civil liberty and property [Rousseau]
7242 Appetite alone is slavery, and self-prescribed laws are freedom [Rousseau]
19799 Private property must always be subordinate to ownership by the whole community [Rousseau]
19800 The social compact imposes conventional equality of rights on people who may start unequally [Rousseau]
19798 Ancient monarchs were kings of peoples; modern monarchs more cleverly rule a land [Rousseau]
19801 Sovereignty is the exercise of the general will, which can never be delegated [Rousseau]
7243 Silence of the people implies their consent [Rousseau]
7244 The general will is common interest; the will of all is the sum of individual desires [Rousseau]
19802 The general will is always right, but the will of all can err, because it includes private interests [Rousseau]
19803 If the state contains associations there are fewer opinions, undermining the general will [Rousseau]
19804 If a large knowledgeable population votes in isolation, their many choices will have good results [Rousseau]
19808 The general will changes its nature when it focuses on particulars [Rousseau]
19805 Just as people control their limbs, the general-will state has total control of its members [Rousseau]
19807 Both nature and reason require that everything has a cause [Rousseau]
19806 We alienate to society only what society needs - but society judges that, not us [Rousseau]
19811 Only people who are actually dangerous should be executed, even as an example [Rousseau]
19809 We accept the death penalty to prevent assassinations, so we must submit to it if necessary [Rousseau]
19810 A trial proves that a criminal has broken the social treaty, and is no longer a member of the state [Rousseau]
7245 Natural justice, without sanctions, benefits the wicked, who exploit it [Rousseau]
7246 The general will is always good, but sometimes misunderstood [Rousseau]
19812 Human nature changes among a people, into a moral and partial existence [Rousseau]
19814 A state must be big enough to preserve itself, but small enough to be governable [Rousseau]
19815 Too much land is a struggle, producing defensive war; too little makes dependence, and offensive war [Rousseau]
19816 A state's purpose is liberty and equality - liberty for strength, and equality for liberty [Rousseau]
7247 The greatest social good comes down to freedom and equality [Rousseau]
7248 No citizen should be rich enough to buy another, and none so poor as forced to sell himself [Rousseau]
19819 The state ensures liberty, so civil law separates citizens, and binds them to the state [Rousseau]
19818 Political laws are fundamental, as they firmly organise the state - but they could still be changed [Rousseau]
19817 Citizens should be independent of each other, and very dependent on the state [Rousseau]
19820 The state has a legislature and an executive, just like the will and physical power in a person [Rousseau]
19821 I call the executive power the 'government', which is the 'prince' - a single person, or a group [Rousseau]
19822 If the state enlarges, the creators of the general will become less individually powerful [Rousseau]
19823 If the population is larger, the government needs to be more powerful [Rousseau]
19824 Large populations needs stronger control, which means power should be concentrated [Rousseau]
19826 Democracy for small states, aristocracy for intermediate, monarchy for large [Rousseau]
19825 If the sovereign entrusts government to at least half the citizens, that is 'democracy' [Rousseau]
19827 Law makers and law implementers should be separate [Rousseau]
19829 Natural aristocracy is primitive, and hereditary is dreadful, but elective aristocracy is best [Rousseau]
7249 Natural aristocracy is primitive, hereditary is bad, and elective aristocracy is the best [Rousseau]
19828 Democracy leads to internal strife, as people struggle to maintain or change ways of ruling [Rousseau]
19835 When ministers change the state changes, because they always reverse policies [Rousseau]
19832 Democratic elections are dangerous intervals in government [Rousseau]
19830 Large states need a nobility to fill the gap between a single prince and the people [Rousseau]
19831 The highest officers under a monarchy are normally useless; the public could choose much better [Rousseau]
19834 Attempts to train future kings don't usually work, and the best have been unprepared [Rousseau]
19833 Hereditary monarchy is easier, but can lead to dreadful monarchs [Rousseau]
19836 The amount of taxation doesn't matter, if it quickly circulates back to the citizens [Rousseau]
19837 If inhabitants are widely dispersed, organising a revolt is much more difficult [Rousseau]
19838 The measure of a successful state is increase in its population [Rousseau]
19839 The flourishing of arts and letters is too much admired [Rousseau]
7250 Laws are authentic acts of the general will [Rousseau]
19840 A citizen is a subject who is also sovereign [Rousseau]
7251 The English are actually slaves in between elections [Rousseau]
19841 Sometimes full liberty is only possible at the expense of some complete enslavement [Rousseau]
19842 The government is instituted by a law, not by a contract [Rousseau]
19844 Assemblies must always confirm the form of government, and the current administration [Rousseau]
19843 The state is not bound to leave civil authority to its leaders [Rousseau]
19846 The more unanimous the assembly, the stronger the general will becomes [Rousseau]
19847 We can never assume that the son of a slave is a slave [Rousseau]
19848 The sovereignty does not appoint the leaders [Rousseau]
19849 In early theocracies the god was the king, and there were as many gods as nations [Rousseau]
19850 By separating theological and political systems, Jesus caused divisions in the state [Rousseau]
19851 Every society has a religion as its base [Rousseau]
19852 Civil religion needs one supreme god, an afterlife, justice, and the sanctity of the social contract [Rousseau]
19853 All religions should be tolerated, if they tolerate each other, and support citizenship [Rousseau]
7252 A tyrant exploits Christians because they don't value this life, and are made to be slaves [Rousseau]
23607 Wars are between States, not people, and the individuals are enemies by accident [Rousseau]