more on this theme | more from this thinker
Full Idea
Constitution-without-identity is superior to constitution-as-identity in that it provides a unified view of the relation between persons and bodies, statues and pieces of bronze, and so on.
Gist of Idea
The constitution view gives a unified account of the relation of persons/bodies, statues/bronze etc
Source
Lynne Rudder Baker (Why Constitution is not Identity [1997], IV)
Book Ref
-: 'Journal of Philosophy' [-], p.613
A Reaction
I have a problem with the intrinsic dualism of this whole picture. Clay needs shape, statues need matter - there aren't two 'things' here which have a 'relation'.
Related Idea
Idea 16067 Constitution is not identity, because it is an asymmetric dependence relation [Wasserman]
| 16076 | Constitution is not identity, as consideration of essential predicates shows [Rudder Baker] |
| 16078 | Clay is intrinsically and atomically the same as statue (and that lacks 'modal properties') [Rudder Baker] |
| 16080 | Is it possible for two things that are identical to become two separate things? [Rudder Baker] |
| 16081 | The constitution view gives a unified account of the relation of persons/bodies, statues/bronze etc [Rudder Baker] |
| 16077 | The clay is not a statue - it borrows that property from the statue it constitutes [Rudder Baker] |
| 16082 | Statues essentially have relational properties lacked by lumps [Rudder Baker] |