structure for 'Mind and Body'    |     alphabetical list of themes    |     expand these ideas

17. Mind and Body / E. Physicalism / 7. Anti-Physicalism / e. Modal argument

[surely mind-brain connections are necessary?]

5 ideas
Pain, unlike heat, is picked out by an essential property [Kripke]
Kripke says pain is necessarily pain, but a brain state isn't necessarily painful [Rey on Kripke]
Identity must be necessary, but pain isn't necessarily a brain state, so they aren't identical [Schwartz,SP on Kripke]
Identity theorists seem committed to no-brain-event-no-pain, and vice versa, which seems wrong [Kripke]
If consciousness could separate from brain, then it cannot be identical with brain [Papineau]