green numbers give full details | back to texts | unexpand this idea
| 9226 | If mathematical theories conflict, it may just be that they have different subject matter |
| Full Idea: Unlike logic, in the case of mathematics there may be no genuine conflict between alternative theories: it is natural to think that different theories, if both consistent, are simply about different subjects. | |||
| From: Hartry Field (Recent Debates on the A Priori [2005], 7) | |||
| A reaction: For this reason Field places logic at the heart of questions about a priori knowledge, rather than mathematics. My intuitions make me doubt his proposal. Given the very simple basis of, say, arithmetic, I would expect all departments to connect. |