display all the ideas for this combination of texts
3 ideas
4936 | The self is founded on bodily awareness centred in the brain stem [Edelman/Tononi] |
Full Idea: Structures in the brain stem map the state of the body and its relation to the environment, on the basis of signals with proprioceptive, kinesthetic, somatosensory and autonomic components. We may call these the dimensions of the proto-self. | |
From: G Edelman / G Tononi (Consciousness: matter becomes imagination [2000], Ch.13) | |
A reaction: It seems to me that there is no free will, but moral responsibility depends on the existence of a Self, and philosophers had better fight for it (are you listening, Hume?). Fortunately neuroscientists seem to endorse it fairly unanimously. |
4939 | A sense of self begins either internally, or externally through language and society [Edelman/Tononi] |
Full Idea: Two extreme views on the development of the self are 'internalist' and 'externalist'. The first starts with a baby's subjective experience, and increasing differentiation as self-consciousness develops. The externalist view requires language and society. | |
From: G Edelman / G Tononi (Consciousness: matter becomes imagination [2000], Ch.15) | |
A reaction: Edelman rightly warns against this simple dichotomy, but if I have to vote, it is for internalism. I take a sense of self as basic to any mind, even a slug's. What is a mind for, if not to look after the creature? Self makes sensation into mind. |
4925 | Brains can initiate free actions before the person is aware of their own decision [Edelman/Tononi] |
Full Idea: Libet concluded that the cerebral initiation of a spontaneous, freely voluntary act can begin unconsciously, that is, before there is any recallable awareness that a decision to act has already been initiated cerebrally. | |
From: G Edelman / G Tononi (Consciousness: matter becomes imagination [2000], Ch. 6) | |
A reaction: We should accept this result. 'Free will' was always a bogus metaphysical concept (invented, I think, because God had to be above natural laws). A person is the source of responsibility, and is the controller of the brain, but not entirely conscious. |