display all the ideas for this combination of texts
5 ideas
23928 | Good art produces exaltation and detachment [Bell,C] |
Full Idea: The contemplation of pure form leads to a state of extraordinary exaltation and complete detachment from the concerns of life. | |
From: Clive Bell (Art [1913], I.III) | |
A reaction: The last part is what gets the arts a bad name with the people who do deal with the concerns of life (which won't go away, even for an artist!). However, being totally trapped in the concerns of life is probably a recipe for misery. |
23922 | The word 'beauty' leads to confusion, because it denotes distinct emotions [Bell,C] |
Full Idea: The word 'beauty' connotes objects of quite distinguishable emotions, and the term would land me in confusions and misunderstandings. | |
From: Clive Bell (Art [1913], I.I) | |
A reaction: His main example is a comparison of beautiful women with beautiful art. Personally I don't think the word aspires to be precise, so there is no problem. Maths has beautiful solutions, golf has beautiful shots, cooking has beautiful results. Wow! |
23929 | We only see landscapes as artistic if we ignore their instrumental value [Bell,C] |
Full Idea: It is only when we cease to regard the objects in a landscape as means to anything that we can feel the landscape artistically. | |
From: Clive Bell (Art [1913], II.I) | |
A reaction: This sounds as if only the exploitative attitude blocks the artistic view, but I would expect the scientific view (of an ecologist, for example) to do the same. |
23921 | Our feeling for natural beauty is different from the aesthetic emotion of art [Bell,C] |
Full Idea: It is not what I call an aesthetic emotion that most of us feel, generally, for natural beauty. …Most people feel a very different kind of emotion for birds, flowers and butterfly wings from that we feel for pictures, pots, temples and statues. | |
From: Clive Bell (Art [1913], I.I) | |
A reaction: Not convinced. I think the main difference is our awareness that art is a human production, the result of choice, whereas nature is a given. Beethoven 9 and a good sunset don't seem to me far apart in our responses. |
23923 | Visual form can create a sublime mental state [Bell,C] |
Full Idea: Pure visual form transports me to an infinitely sublime state of mind. | |
From: Clive Bell (Art [1913], I.I) | |
A reaction: Unusual for anyone to use to term 'sublime' for works of art, and I suspect that Bell was the last to do so. Bell offers a quasi-religious role for art. I accept that being struck by something exceptionally good in art is a very distinctive experience. |