display all the ideas for this combination of texts
56 ideas
2803 | Man is by nature a political animal [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Man is by nature a political animal. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1253a01) | |
A reaction: It might be clearer if we said 'social animal'. We are certainly gregarious. Anyone who fails to be social is dismissed by Aristotle as not truly human. |
2820 | People want to live together, even when they don't want mutual help [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Men have a desire for live together, even when they have no need to seek each other's help. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1278b20) | |
A reaction: He says that someone who doesn't want to live in community because they are wholly self-sufficient doesn't count as a normal human. |
22586 | Only humans have reason [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The human being alone has reason. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1332b04) | |
A reaction: Only in the last fifty years have we begun to grasp how clever larger animals are, and I would say that they consistently make rational choices, even if they can't articulate them. |
22523 | The community (of villages) becomes a city when it is totally self-sufficient [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The community, coming from several villages, when it is complete, is the city, once it has already reached (one might almost say) the limit of total self-sufficiency. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1252b27) | |
A reaction: I suppose a group of villages might be self-sufficient, provided water supply and defences were secure. In a city it is all within easy reach. Each village can't have a full set of specialists. |
2805 | A community must share a common view of good and justice [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is sharing a common view in good and evil, justice and injustice, that makes a household and a state. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1253a17) | |
A reaction: This idea comes up against the modern idea of pluralism (e.g. in Isaiah Berlin), which is inevitable in huge states with a lot of migration. |
22526 | People who are anti-social or wholly self-sufficient are no part of a city [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Anyone who cannot live in a community with others, or who does not need to because of his self-sufficiency, is no part of a city, so that he is either a wild beast or a god. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1253a27) | |
A reaction: Civil people should try hard to accommodate those who are anti-social. I'm not convinced that there is anyone who is wholly self-sufficient. |
22535 | Friendship is the best good for cities, because it reduces factions [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: We think friendship is the greatest good for cities, since this way people are least likely to engage in faction. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1262b07) | |
A reaction: Earlier philosophers were deeply worried about 'faction', but we now accept the gangs of secretive hoodlums called political parties. I suspect the old view was right, but it's a bit late now. You can't engineer friendships (can you?). |
22532 | A city can't become entirely one, because its very nature is to be a multitude [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Socrates adopts the hypothesis that it is best for a city to be as far as possible entirely one. …But it is evident that the more a city becomes one the less of a city it will be. For a city is in its nature a sort of multitude. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1261a14) | |
A reaction: [He is referring to Plato's Republic] He says if a city wholly unifies it becomes like a household, and then a human being, rather than a city. A very interesting commitment to diversity in a city, based on its essential nature. Athens was very diverse. |
22584 | A community should all share to some extent in something like land or food [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Communities should have some one thing that is common and the same for all the members, whether they share in it equally or unequally - for example, food, a quantity of territory, or something else of this sort. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1328a27) | |
A reaction: In modern societies vast numbers of people own no land at all, and common land has dwindled. Maybe it is roads, buses and trains? |
22581 | The size of a city is decided by the maximum self-sufficient community that can be surveyed [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The best defining mark of a city is the greatest excess of multitude with a view to self-sufficiency in living that can easily be surveyed as a whole. Let the size of the city, then, be determined in this way. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1326b23) | |
A reaction: Modern states have presumably far exceeded to self-sufficiency test. The requirement to be 'surveyed' presumably implies that the state can be controlled. Modern technology means almost no limit to such a size. |
22548 | A city aims at living well [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The end of the city is living well. …It is for the sake of noble actions, not for the sake of living together. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1280b38) | |
A reaction: So the aim is not glory, conquest, colonisation, great buildings or other works. It is all of the citizens living well in their own way. This is the liberal ideal, from a long time ago. Spinoza is in tune with this. Fulfilling capabilities? |
22577 | What is the best life for everyone, and is that a communal or an individual problem? [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: There should first be agreement about what the most choiceworthy life is for (one might almost say) everyone, and then determine whether it is the same or distinct for all communally as for each separately. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1323a19) | |
A reaction: Presumably 'almost' because slaves don't make the cut. But the inclusiveness is hugely important, and I take his second question to be the debate between communitarians and liberals. Communists and libertarians might get a look in. |
22579 | The same four cardinal virtues which apply to individuals also apply to a city [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The courage, justice, practical wisdom, and temperance of a city have the same capacity and form [morphé] as those in which each human being who is said to be courageous, just, practically-wise, and temperate would share. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1323b33) | |
A reaction: These are the four traditional Cardinal Virtues of ancient Greek culture. Aristotle defers to them, even though his account of the virtues is much broader. |
2431 | Every state is an association formed for some good purpose [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Observation tells us that every state is an association; and that every state is formed with a view to some good purpose. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1252a01) | |
A reaction: Not so much a historical speculation, I think, as an assertion that it should be obvious what binds a state together, and hence has allowed it to endure. |
22578 | The happiest city is the one that acts most nobly [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The happy city is the one that is best and acts nobly. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1323b29) | |
A reaction: He applies almost identical criteria to the eudaimon individual and the eudaimon city. It is not the possession of virtuous qualities but the performing of fine deeds which matters. I want to be proud of what my country does. |
2832 | The state aims to consist as far as possible of those who are like and equal [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The state aims to consist as far as possible of those who are like and equal. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1295b25) | |
A reaction: He knows that this cannot be fully achieved. It gets worrying when misfits are pressured into conformity. This sounds like Aristotle's less liberal side - though he accepts diversity. |
2821 | The six constitutions are monarchy/tyranny, aristocracy/oligarchy, and polity/democracy [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The names for right constitutions (with their deviations) are monarchy (tyranny), aristocracy (oligarchy), and polity (democracy). | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1279b04) | |
A reaction: I found it hard to pin down the meaning of 'polity', even though he makes it sound like the best constitution. Something like 'teamwork'. |
22546 | A city is a community of free people, and the constitution should aim at the common advantage [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Those constitutions that aim at the common advantage are correct, whereas those that aim only at the advantage of the rulers are erroneous ones. For they are like the rule of a master, whereas a city is a community of free people. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1279a17) | |
A reaction: He is very keen on the full equality of all citizens (even if his concept of a citizen is narrow). This must be connected to his eudaimonist account of ethics. Everyone must flourish. I'm struck by his liberal values. |
2835 | Any constitution can be made to last for a day or two [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Any constitution can be made to last for a day or two. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1319b35) | |
A reaction: An important issue for Aristotle, which we no longer seem to worry about. A constitution should aim, when it is created, to be acceptable enough to be durable. |
22580 | The best constitution enables everyone to live the best life [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is evident that the best constitution is necessarily that order in accord with which anyone might be able to do best and live blessedly. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1324a23) | |
A reaction: So what would Aristotle make of the modern welfare state, or the idea of a safety net for those who struggle? Should the state help the best life, and not just facilitate it? Education, infrastructure, health, communal activity…. |
22558 | Constitutions specify distribution of offices, the authorities, and the community's aim [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: A constitution is the way that cities order their offices, how they are distributed, what element is in control in the constitution, and what the end of each community is. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1289a15) | |
A reaction: Liberal constitutions tend to avoid stating what the end of the city is, because that is for the free citizens to decide. Nothing is said, it seems, about the territory or the population. |
22566 | The greed of the rich is more destructive than the greed of the people [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: What the rich do to get more does more to destroy the constitution than what the people do. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1297a10) | |
A reaction: Presumably this is because the wealthy have more power. In our society they have more control over the media and public opinions. The law should maintain the constitution, and the poor have no influence on the law. |
2973 | We must decide the most desirable human life before designing a constitution [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: If we wish to investigate the best constitution appropriately, we must first decide what is the most desirable life. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1323a14) | |
A reaction: He takes this for granted, and it sounds right, but it is firmly contradicted by modern liberals (e.g. Rawls), who say the good life is for individuals to decide. |
22563 | The middle classes are neither ambitious nor anarchic, which is good [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Those in the middle [in wealth] are least inclined either to avoid rule or to be eager to rule, both of which things are harmful to cities. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1295b12) | |
A reaction: How nice to hear something good about the poor old middle classes - the hated bourgeoisie of the marxists, looked down on by the snobbish elite. They avoid the black market, and bribery for offices. |
2818 | The virtues of a good citizen are relative to a particular constitution [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The virtue of the citizen must be in relation to the constitution; and as there are many constitutions, there cannot be just one single and perfect virtue of the sound citizen. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1276b28) | |
A reaction: This is very striking support for the view that Aristotle's account of the virtues in 'Ethics' is merely a description of conventions (Athenian, presumably), rather than an appeal to nature. However, see his account of the soul, and human function. |
22545 | A person can be an excellent citizen without being an excellent man [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is possible for someone to be an excellent citizen without having acquired the virtue in accord with which someone is an excellent man. …[1278b02] In one sort of city the good man and the excellent citizen are the same. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1276b33) | |
A reaction: Thus confutes my simple summary of Aristotelian ethics as 'be a good citizen!'. He thinks leaders of communities must be excellent men. You can fulfil a role in the city (soldier, doctor, cleaner) without all-round excellence (see 1276b39). |
22544 | A citizen is someone who is allowed to hold official posts in a city [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Whoever is authorised to share in deliberative or judicial office …is a citizen of the relevant city. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1275b18) | |
A reaction: Interesting, and perhaps a bit surprising for us. We tend to assume that in a democracy the citizens are those allowed to vote, but he says what matters is being allowed to hold an office. Log cabin to White House. He's right. |
22541 | Kings should be selected according to character [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is surely better to choose each new king not as now but rather in accord with his own life. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1271a20) | |
A reaction: When the British monarch was very powerful, the hereditary system was fairly disastrous. I get a thrill when a highly esteemed citizen is voted president of a country, such as Vaclav Havel in Czechia. British monarchs could be elected. |
2819 | The only virtue special to a ruler is practical wisdom [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The only virtue special to a ruler is practical wisdom. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1277b27) | |
A reaction: If a person with wide social powers is to have practical wisdom, that will require extensive knowledge, in a way that local practical wisdom does not. |
22542 | People who buy public office will probably expect to profit from it [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is reasonable to expect that those who have bought office, that is, when they rule by having spent money, will become habituated to making a profit from it. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1273b01) | |
A reaction: Probably true, though money-grubbers are even happier if they can achieve office without expenditure. |
22552 | The rich can claim to rule, because of land ownership, and being more trustworthy [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The rich have a claim because they own a larger share of the land, and the land is something communal, and furthermore because they are for the most part more trustworthy when it comes to treaties. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1283a32) | |
A reaction: It seems right that the rich give a stability and hence reliability to a society, which the more mobile poor cannot offer. But it is a minor point. |
22583 | The guardians should not be harsh to strangers, as no one should behave like that [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is not correct to claim that guardians are to be harsh to those they do not know, since one should not treat anyone in this way. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1328a07) | |
A reaction: This seems to be a criticism of Plato. Aristotle thinks people should be nice to one another! The ancient tradition of hospitality to strangers. |
22543 | In large communities it is better if more people participate in the offices [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Where the city is not small, it is more political and more democratic, if more people participate in the offices. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1273b11) | |
A reaction: Not sure what 'more political' means. This is not to avoid corruption, but because it is best to have specialists in everything. All of the state functions should be of the highest standard. |
22539 | Election of officials by the elected is dangerous, because factions can control it [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Where the election of officials is concerned, electing from the elected is dangerous. For if some are willing to combine, even if they are a relatively small number, the election will always turn out according to their wish. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1266a25) | |
A reaction: The British Prime Minister is elected by the elected members of parliament of the majority party. (Boris Johnson is the current PM…). This idea reflects the great concern that earlier thinkers had about factions in politics. |
22572 | Officers should like the constitution, be capable, and have appropriate virtues and justice [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Those holding the controlling offices should possess friendship towards the constitution, great capacity for that office, and the virtue and justice required by that constitution. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1309a33) | |
A reaction: We need to remember that all officers in our democracy need to be fully committed to that system of government (which does not always seem to me to be the case). |
2826 | Like water, large numbers of people are harder to corrupt than a few [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: As a larger amount of water is less easily polluted, so the multitude is less easily corrupted than the few. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1286a30) | |
A reaction: This was before the arrival of modern mass media, starting with tabloid newspapers. When many people are corrupted, it is much harder for society to recover its sanity. |
22567 | Democracy arises when people who are given equal freedom assume unconditional equality [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Democracy arose from those who are equal in some respect thinking themselves to be unconditionally equal, since, because they are equally free, they think they are unconditionally equal. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1301a28) | |
A reaction: An interesting speculation. In Britain the origins of democracy seem tied to the granting of religious equality and freedom. |
22560 | Popular leaders only arise in democracies that are not in accord with the law [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: In cities under democracies that are in accord with law, popular leaders do not arise, but rather it is the best citizens who take the front seats. Where the laws are not in control, however, there popular leaders arise. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1292a07) | |
A reaction: This remark is, unfortunately, highly relevant to western politics in 2020. He says that flatterers rise to the top in these regimes. |
22562 | Choosing officials by lot is democratic [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It seems to be democratic for officials to be chosen by lot. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1294b07) | |
A reaction: This idea has dropped out of modern politics, but is not ridiculous if the official is offered thorough civil service support. Presumably the term of office is fairly short. |
2823 | The many may add up to something good, even if they are inferior as individuals [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is possible that the many, not one of whom taken singly is a sound man, may yet, taken all together, be better than the few, not individually but collectively. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1281b01) | |
A reaction: They may also crush everything that is good, if the many are gripped by absurd ideas (which they often are). Computer programmers are a good advert for this idea. |
22533 | If the people are equal in nature, then they should all share in ruling [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Where it is not possible for the same people always to rule, because all are in nature equal, it is also just for all to share in ruling. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1261a38) | |
A reaction: This derives from his principle that the naturally superior should always rule the naturally inferior - though it sometimes looks as if ruling is the distinguishing mark of who is 'superior'. Democracy needs to equalise its citizens, where possible. |
2817 | It is wrong that a worthy officer of state should seek the office [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is all wrong that a person who is going to be deemed worthy of an office should solicit it. …One worthy of the office should hold it whether he wishes to or does not wish to. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1271a10) | |
A reaction: I love this idea, and think it should be immediately implemented in the modern world, at every level of society. All leaders should be pushed to the front. The ambitious should be pulled to the back. |
22576 | No office is permanent in a democracy [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is democratic to have no office be permanent. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1317b42) | |
A reaction: Modern exceptions seem to be judges and civil servants. |
22549 | In many cases, the claim that the majority is superior would apply equally to wild beasts [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Whether in every people this superiority of the majority to the few excellent people can exist is not clear. In some of them this cannot possibly be so, since the same argument would apply to wild beasts. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1281b18) | |
A reaction: He also gives reasons why it is plausible to think that the judgement of the majority is superior. It seems crucial that the majority have some education. Education is pointless if it is always overruled by the uneducated. |
22575 | Ultimate democracy is tyranny [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The ultimate democracy is a tyranny. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1312b05) | |
A reaction: Presumably this is rule by a majority which has been corrupted by a populist leader, resulting in things like witch hunts. |
22531 | We aim to understand the best possible community for free people [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Our project is to get a theoretical grasp on which political community is superior to all others for people who are able to live as far as possible in the way they would pray to live. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1260b28) | |
A reaction: This strikes me as a manifesto for liberalism. Presumably a community of free people starts from a superior position, and so the ideal community is the best that can be achieved from that starting point. A utopia of slaves is of no interest. |
22564 | Community is based on friends, who are equal and similar, and share things [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Community is fitted to friendship, since enemies do not wish to share even a road in common. But a city tends to consist as much as possible of people who are equal and similar, which especially holds of those in the middle. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1295b24) | |
A reaction: The surprising emphasis on friendship in 'Ethics' turns out to have great importance in 'Politics'. Friendship is the cement of a community, and the constitution must maximise good conditions for friendships. |
22585 | Look at all of the citizens before judging a city to be happy [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: A city must not be called happy by looking at just a part of it, but by looking at all of the citizens. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1329a22) | |
A reaction: For example, it is wrong for a state to exult for being on the winning side in a major war, if it has meant misery for much of their own population. The Field of the Cloth of Gold (1520) does not excuse the misery of vagrants. |
22565 | The best communities rely on a large and strong middle class [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The political community that is due to those in the middle class is best, and cities can be well governed where the middle class is numerous and strong. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1295b34) | |
A reaction: He specifically connects this to the doctrine of the mean in 'Ethics'. It seems easier for rulers from the middle classes to command universal respect, as the extremes tend to despise one another. What does he mean by 'strong'? |
22589 | Citizens do not just own themselves, but are also parts of the city [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: One should in no way think that any citizen belongs to himself alone, but that all of them belong to the city, each being part of the city. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1337a27) | |
A reaction: Note that they do not belong entirely to the city. I take this as an expression of his liberalism, which reminds liberals that we are also parts of a community, with a common good, and can't just go our own way. |
22534 | People care less about what is communal, and more about what is their own [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: What is held communally by the most people gets the least care. For people give most thought to what is their own, less to what is communal, or only as much as falls to each of them to give. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1261b33) | |
A reaction: That is, they care about the bit they contributed (I think). On a train, would people with feet on the seats do the same in their own home? Yes, probably! Caring about what is communal must be a cultural consensus. Pride in the NHS. |
23750 | It is not more money which the wretched members of society need [Weil] |
Full Idea: Suppose the devil were bargaining for the soul of some wretch, and some pitying person said to the devil 'Shame on you, that commodity is worth twice as much'. Such is the sinister farce played by the working class unions, parties and intellectuals. | |
From: Simone Weil (Human Personality [1943], p.80) | |
A reaction: A striking thought. It is paradoxical when the working classes despise the middle classes, and yet aspire to be like them. It's hard to know what a mystic like Weil has in mind. An obvious thought is that the aspiration should be freedom, not money. |
22538 | Owning and sharing property communally increases disagreements [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Those who own and share property communally have far more disagreements than those who own their property separately. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1263b23) | |
A reaction: The reduction of disagreements is not a trivial matter, when designing a constitution for a happy community. 'Good fences make good neighbours'. |
22536 | There could be private land and public crops, or public land and private crops, or both public [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The land might be held separately, while the crops grown on it are brought into a communal store, …or the land might he held and farmed communally, while the crops are divided for private use, …or they could both be held communally. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1263a02) | |
A reaction: Aristotle says that examples exist of both of the first two cases. I would go for public land and privately divided crops. Capitalists end up with private land and private crops. |
23749 | The problem of the collective is not suppression of persons, but persons erasing themselves [Weil] |
Full Idea: The chief danger does not lie in the collectivity's tendency to circumscribe the person, but in the person's tendency to immolate himself in the collective. | |
From: Simone Weil (Human Personality [1943], p.78) | |
A reaction: I'm guessing that in 1943 she had in mind both Nazis and Communists. She seems to articulate a strong form of liberalism in an interesting way. It sounds like a form of Bad Faith. |
22530 | Both women and children should be educated, as this contributes to a city's excellence [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is necessary to look to the constitution in educating both women and children, if indeed it makes any difference to the excellence of a city that its children be excellent, and its women too. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1260b14) | |
A reaction: He consistently classes women as inferior, so it is a bit surprising to find that women need to be educated. They are not full citizens, but are part of the community, of which all parts need to be excellent. |