display all the ideas for this combination of texts
10 ideas
22573 | The virtue of justice may be relative to a particular constitution [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: If what is just is not the same in all constitutions, there must be differences in the virtue of justice as well. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1309a37) | |
A reaction: This problem has recently arisen when the state of China took full control of the westernised colony of Hong Kong. Liberals look for a more absolute concept of justice. What is justice in a slave colony? |
2825 | The good is obviously justice, which benefits the whole community, and involves equality in some sense [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: In a state the good aimed at is justice; and that means what is for the benefit of the whole community; and all men believe that justice means equality in some sense. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1282b17) | |
A reaction: Aristotle's idea of justice seems closer to finding what is appropriate than it does to mere equality of treatment. |
22527 | Justice is the order in a political community [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Justice is a political community's order. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1253a36) | |
A reaction: This seems to agree with Plato, who identifies justice with harmony (in individuals as well as in communities). Fascism, however, tries to impose order without justice. Maybe justice is the health of the community. |
22547 | Justice is equality for equals, and inequality for unequals [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Justice seems to be equality - not for everyone, but for equals. Justice also seems to be inequality - not for everyone, but for unequals. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1280a11) | |
A reaction: He is specific that slaves, women and children are unequals, but I'm not sure how much inequality there is among the free men. In virtue theory, some men are clearly greatly superior to others. Is there a cut off point for equality? |
22556 | Laws that match people's habits are more effective than mere written rules [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Laws that are in accord with habits have more control and deal with things that have more control than do written laws. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1287b05) | |
A reaction: This is the problem of bringing the law into disrepute, by insisting on behaviour that goes against the grain. But there are laws, such as those against racism, which are designed to break bad habits. |
2816 | If it is easy to change the laws, that makes them weaker [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Easy change from established laws to new laws means weakening the power of the law. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1269a23) | |
A reaction: This is a reasonable justification for sometimes insisting on the letter of the law, even though some degree of injustice results. |
2806 | Man is the worst of all animals when divorced from law and justice [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: Man is the worst of all animals when divorced from law and justice. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1253a31) | |
A reaction: Sounds true, but it is extraordinary that the virtues of mankind only emerge when we are artificially contrained. Rousseau disagreed with this. |
22551 | Correct law should be in control, with rulers only deciding uncertain issues [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: The laws, when correctly laid down, should be in control, and the ruler, whether one or many, should have control only of those matters on which the laws cannot pronounce with exactness. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1282b01) | |
A reaction: It is obvious that general laws cannot cover each individual cases. Aristotle doesn't yet have the concept of an independent judiciary to handle this problem, so this is not true separation of powers. |
22554 | It is said that we should not stick strictly to written law, as it is too vague [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is said that laws speak only of the universal, and do not prescribe with a view to particular circumstances, so that it is foolish to rule in any craft in accord with what is written down. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1286a10) | |
A reaction: To say we shouldn't follow laws because they are all vague would be crazy. A vague border is still a border. Laws need interpretation, and judgement of appropriate application. |
2827 | It is preferable that law should rule rather than any single citizen [Aristotle] |
Full Idea: It is preferable that law should rule rather than any single citizen. | |
From: Aristotle (Politics [c.332 BCE], 1287a19) | |
A reaction: This assumes that the law is sensible. An exception would be when a wise ruler takes over a very corrupted state, which has passed evil laws. Nelson Mandela. |