display all the ideas for this combination of texts
2 ideas
10749 | Necessary truths seem to all have the same truth-maker [Oliver] |
Full Idea: The definition of truth-makers entails that a truth-maker for a given necessary truth is equally a truth-maker for every other necessary truth. | |
From: Alex Oliver (The Metaphysics of Properties [1996], §24) | |
A reaction: Maybe we could accept this. Necessary truths concern the way things have to be, so all realities will embody them. Are we to say that nothing makes a necessary truth true? |
10750 | Slingshot Argument: seems to prove that all sentences have the same truth-maker [Oliver] |
Full Idea: Slingshot Argument: if truth-makers work for equivalent sentences and co-referring substitute sentences, then if 'the numbers + S1 = the numbers' has a truth-maker, then 'the numbers + S2 = the numbers' will have the same truth-maker. | |
From: Alex Oliver (The Metaphysics of Properties [1996], §24) | |
A reaction: [compressed] Hence every sentence has the same truth-maker! Truth-maker fans must challenge one of the premises. |