21547
|
On Meinong's principles 'the existent round square' has to exist [Russell]
|
|
Full Idea:
To my contention that, on his principles, 'the existent round square' exists, Meinong replies that it is existent but does not exist. I must confess that I see no difference between existing and being existent, and I have no more to say on this head.
|
|
From:
Bertrand Russell (Review: Meinong 'Uber die Stellung...' [1907], p.93)
|
|
A reaction:
Russell is obviously invoking the famously dubious ontological argument for God's existence. Normally impossible objects are rejected because of contradictions, but there might also be category mistakes. 'The slow square'.
|
13267
|
Temporal parts is a crazy doctrine, because it entails constantly creating stuff ex nihilo [Thomson, by Koslicki]
|
|
Full Idea:
Thomson famously objects that the doctrine of temporal parts is 'a crazy metaphysic - obviously false', since it entails that material objects are constantly being generated ex nihilo (or, at least, the stuff of which they are composed is).
|
|
From:
report of Judith (Jarvis) Thomson (Parthood and Identity across Time [1983], p.210) by Kathrin Koslicki - The Structure of Objects 2.2
|
|
A reaction:
The related objections are to ask what the temporal 'width' of a part is, and whether the joins are visible.
|